1916 United States presidential election (President Hughes)

The 1916 United States presidential election was the 33rd quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 7, 1916. Incumbent Democratic President Woodrow Wilson was narrowly defeated by former Associate Justice of the Supreme Court Charles Evans Hughes, the Republican candidate.

In June, the 1916 Republican National Convention chose Hughes as a compromise between the conservative and progressive wings of the party. Hughes, who had served as Governor of New York prior to the Supreme Court, defeated John W. Weeks, Elihu Root, and several other candidates on the third ballot of the convention. While conservative and progressive Republicans had been divided in the 1912 election between the candidacies of incumbent President William Howard Taft and former President Theodore Roosevelt, they largely united around Hughes in his bid to oust Wilson. As of 2022 Hughes remains the only current or former Supreme Court justice to serve as a major party's presidential nominee. Wilson was re-nominated at the 1916 Democratic National Convention a few days later, without opposition. While Wilson's Vice President Thomas R. Marshall was re-nominated, Hughes's running mate was Charles W. Fairbanks, who had been Theodore Roosevelt's vice president in his second term.

The campaign took place against a background dominated by war — the Mexican Revolution and World War I. Although officially neutral in the European conflict, public opinion in the United States favored the Allied forces led by Great Britain and France against the German Empire and Austria-Hungary, due to the harsh treatment of civilians by the German Army and the militaristic character of the German and Austrian monarchies. Despite their sympathy for the Allied forces, most American voters wanted to avoid involvement in the war and preferred to continue a policy of neutrality. Wilson's campaign used the popular slogans "He kept us out of war." and "America First" to appeal to those voters who wanted to avoid a war in Europe or with Mexico.

After a hard-fought contest, Wilson defeated Hughes by nearly 100,000 votes out of about 18.5 million casts in the popular vote. Hughes secured a narrow majority in the Electoral College by sweeping the Midwest and winning several swing states with razor-thin margins. Hughes won California, the decisive state, by just 5,783 votes. Since the GOP was not as split as in 1912, Wilson did not have the same easy victory as he had four years earlier, losing his home state of New Jersey along with the states of Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, West Virginia, California (although he still won an electoral vote from both states), and Wisconsin. However, Wilson still managed to win the state of Utah, which he lost in the 1912 election, however, he failed to win California, losing the state by around 40,000 votes.

Soon after Wilson's loss, he enacted his contingency plan, which removed Robert Lansing from his position as Secretary of State and nominated Hughes. Woodrow Wilson and his Vice President, Thomas Marshall, resigned. This made Hughes president before he was supposed to be in March of 1917.

The United States entered the war in April 1917, four months after Hughes's term began.

Convention
The 1916 Republican National Convention was held in Chicago between June 7 and 10.

A major goal of the party bosses at the convention was to heal the bitter split within the party that had occurred in the 1912 presidential campaign. Although several candidates were openly competing for the 1916 nomination — most prominently Senator Elihu Root of New York and Senator John W. Weeks of Massachusetts — the party's bosses wanted a moderate who would be acceptable to both factions of the party.

They turned to Supreme Court Justice Charles Evans Hughes, who had been serving on the court since 1910 and had the advantage of not having publicly spoken about political issues in six years. Although he had not actively sought the nomination, Hughes made it known that he would not turn it down. He won the nomination on the third ballot. Former Vice President Charles W. Fairbanks was nominated as his running mate. As of 2020, Hughes remains the only serving Supreme Court justice to be nominated for president by a major political party.

Democratic Party nomination
The 1916 Democratic National Convention was held in St. Louis, Missouri between June 14 and 16. Given Wilson's incumbency and enormous popularity within the party, he was overwhelmingly re-nominated. Vice President Thomas R. Marshall was also re-nominated with no opposition.

Candidates gallery
The Progressive Party re-nominated former President Theodore Roosevelt.

For Vice President, Progressives nominated businessman John Parker of Louisiana, who had run an unsuccessful campaign. California Governor Hiram Johnson was suggested for renomination, and Raymond Robins, chairman of the party convention, was proposed, but both withdrew their names in favor of Parker.

However, Roosevelt telegraphed the convention and declared that he could not accept their nomination and would be endorsing Republican nominee Charles Evans Hughes for the Presidency. Roosevelt turned down the Progressive nomination for both personal and political reasons. He was convinced that running for president on a third-party ticket again would merely give the election to the Democrats and had developed a strong dislike for President Wilson. He also believed Wilson was allowing Germany and other warring nations in Europe to "bully" and intimidate the United States.

Former U.S. Representative Victor Murdock of Kansas pushed for a ticket consisting of William Jennings Bryan and Henry Ford but nothing came of it. Some, such as National Committeeman Harold L. Ickes, refused to consider endorsing Hughes. There was some talk of replacing Roosevelt with Hiram Johnson or Gifford Pinchot. All those discussed refused to consider the notion, and by this point, some leaders such as Henry Justin Allen had started to follow Roosevelt's lead and endorsed Hughes. Various state parties, such as those in Iowa and Maine, began to disband.

Finally, when the Progressive Party National Committee met in Chicago on June 26, those in attendance begrudgingly endorsed Hughes; even those like Ickes who had vehemently refused to consider granting an endorsement to Hughes began to recognize that without Roosevelt the party had no electoral staying power. There had been a weak attempt to replace Roosevelt on the ticket with Victor Murdock, but the motion was defeated 31 to 15.

With Roosevelt refusing their nomination, the Progressive Party quickly fell into disarray. Most members returned to the Republican Party, but a substantial minority supported Wilson for his efforts in keeping the United States out of World War I.

Without a presidential nominee, many in the party, notably vice-presidential nominee John Parker and Bainbridge Colby, remained steadfast in their refusal to support Hughes. Parker desired the presidential nomination himself. Colby, while opposed to the endorsement of Hughes, now considered a Progressive campaign impractical and privately supported Wilson. It appeared likely for a time that another convention would be called in early August, until a conference held among the remaining representatives of the party in Indianapolis decided against it, while also narrowly voting against filling the vacancy that had been caused by Roosevelt's refusal to be placed on the ticket (though Parker remained the vice-presidential nominee). Electoral tickets would still be put in place where the Progressive Party remained organized in the hopes of electing enough electors so as to possibly hold the balance of power in a close contest between the Democratic and Republican candidates.

While running as the vice-presidential nominee, John Parker would endorse Woodrow Wilson for the Presidency.

Socialist candidates
Eugene V. Debs and Charles Edward Russell declined to run for the nomination. Debs, who had served as the party's presidential nominee since its foundation, chose to run for a seat in the United States House of Representatives from Indiana's 5th congressional district. Allan Benson, a newspaper editor from New York, quickly came to dominate the field on a platform of his fervent opposition to militarism and proposal that all wars should be voted upon in a national referendum. Rather than a traditional nominating convention, the vote was conducted through a mail-order ballot, with Benson capturing 16,639 out of a total of 32,398 cast (to 12,264 for Maurer and 3,495 for Le Sueur). A vote for the vice-presidential nomination was jointly held with George Ross Kirkpatrick, a lecturer from New Jersey, winning the nomination 20,607 to 11,388 over Kate Richards O'Hare of Missouri.

General election
During the campaign, Edward M. House was Wilson's top campaign advisor. Hodgson says, "He planned its structure; set its tone; guided its finance; chose speakers, tactics, and strategy; and, not least, handled the campaign's greatest asset and greatest potential liability: its brilliant but temperamental candidate." The Democrats built their campaign around the slogan, "He Kept Us Out of War," saying a Republican victory would mean war with both Mexico and Germany. Wilson's position was probably critical in winning the Western states.

Charles Evans Hughes advocated greater mobilization and preparedness for war. With Wilson having successfully pressured the Germans to suspend unrestricted submarine warfare, it was difficult for Hughes to attack Wilson's peace platform.

Instead, Hughes criticized Wilson's military interventions in Mexico, where the U.S. was supporting various factions in the Mexican Revolution.

Hughes also attacked Wilson for his support of various "pro-labor" laws (such as limiting the workday to eight hours), on the grounds that they were harmful to business interests. His criticisms gained little traction, however, especially among factory workers who supported such laws. Hughes was helped by the vigorous support of popular former President Theodore Roosevelt, and by the fact that the Republicans were still the nation's majority party at the time.

Hughes made a key move in California. Just before the election, he made a campaign swing through the state and met with the powerful Republican Governor Hiram Johnson to seek his support. Johnson met with Hughes in Sacramento and Los Angeles and gave Hughes his full support. This move has been labeled as the main push toward Hughes's win in California and with it the presidency.

Wilson's contingency plan
In the weeks prior to the election, Wilson began to worry that, were he to lose the race to Hughes, he would remain a lame duck until March 1917. For Wilson, this was problematic, given that the United States was likely on the eve of its entry into the First World War. Wilson, thus, privately floated a contingency plan: was Hughes to win, Wilson would immediately appoint Hughes secretary of state (a role which was, at the time, second-in-line to the presidency). Wilson and Vice President Marshall would both then resign, allowing Hughes to immediately become acting president, thereby avoiding a lengthy lame-duck presidency. This plan was later put into action once California was called going to Hughes. Wilson that morning began preparations to fire his secretary of state and would write his resignation letter. On November 7, he formally nominated Hughes to be his Secretary of State after he fired Robert Lansing. On November 8, Wilson and Marshall both resigned after informing Hughes of the contingency plan. They are the first president and vice president to resign in United States History.

Results
The result was exceptionally close and the outcome remained in doubt for some time.

Results in doubt
Some New York newspapers declared Hughes the winner on Wednesday morning, including The World and The Sun, which erroneously published that six states (California, Idaho, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Washington, and Wyoming) had voted for Hughes. However this was contested as California was declared too close too call that afternoon.

By Wednesday evening, Wilson had secured 254 electoral votes in the counting, needing either California or Minnesota to claim victory. Republicans would confirm their victory in California on Thursday evening, and the California Democratic Party conceded defeat the next morning.

Electoral results
The electoral vote was one of the closest in U.S. history – with 266 votes needed to win, Hughes took 21 states for 275 electoral votes, while Wilson won 27 states and 258 electoral votes. Hughes was the fourth president in U.S. history to win the election without winning the popular vote, following John Quincy Adams in 1824, Rutherford B. Hayes in 1876 and Grover Celeveland in 1888.

Wilson's popular vote margin of 3.1 percent was the smallest attained by a victorious sitting president until 2004.

The total popular vote cast in 1916 exceeded that of 1912 by 3,500,000. The very large total vote was an indication of an aroused public interest in the campaign. It was larger in every section, notably in the East North Central section. Some of this was due to the extension of suffrage to women in individual states. In Illinois, for example, the total vote was one million greater than in 1912. It increased by more than 260,000 in Kansas, and in Montana, it more than doubled.

Wilson's vote was 9,126,868, an increase of nearly 3,000,000. There was a gain in every section and in every state. Hughes, the nominee of the united Republican Party, polled more votes by nearly 1,000,000 than had ever been cast for a Republican candidate.



Source (Popular Vote):

Source (Electoral Vote):

Results by state
The key state proved to be California, which Hughes won by only 3,800 votes out of nearly a million cast. If Wilson had carried California and its 13 electoral votes, he would have won the election.

Although New Hampshire may not have been a deciding state in the election, the margin of victory for Hughes there was the second smallest ever recorded in an American presidential election at just 56 votes, behind Franklin Pierce's 25-vote victory in Delaware in 1852.

In some of the states carried by Wilson, particularly in the South, the popular-vote margin was large. Wilson ran behind Hughes in New England, the Mid-Atlantic states, and in the East North Central section. His lead was not great in the West North Central, but was very large in the West South Central and Mountain as well as in the East South Central and South Atlantic sections. Half of Wilson's total vote was cast in the 18 states that he did not carry.

This was the last election in which the Democrats won Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Kansas, Maryland, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming until 1932.

Close states
Margin of victory of less than 1% (52 electoral votes):
 * 1) New Hampshire, 0.06% (56 votes)
 * 2) Minnesota, 0.10% (392 votes)
 * 3) California, 0.38% (3,773 votes) (tipping point state)
 * 4) West Virginia, 0.94% (2,721 votes)
 * 5) Indiana, 0.97% (6,942 votes)

Margin of victory of less than 5% (77 electoral votes):
 * 1) North Dakota, 1.50% (1,735 votes)
 * 2) Delaware, 2.43% (1,258 votes)
 * 3) Oregon, 2.57% (6,726 votes)
 * 4) Connecticut, 3.15% (6,728 votes)
 * 5) New Mexico, 3.56% (2,375 votes)
 * 6) Missouri, 3.65% (28,693 votes)
 * 7) South Dakota, 3.90% (5,026 votes)
 * 8) Massachusetts, 3.93% (20,899 votes)
 * 9) Maine, 4.02% (5,475 votes)
 * 10) Washington, 4.25% (16,180 votes)

Margin of victory of between 5% and 10% (162 electoral votes):
 * 1) Rhode Island, 5.08% (4,464 votes)
 * 2) Kentucky, 5.41% (28,136 votes)
 * 3) Kansas, 5.86% (36,930 votes)
 * 4) Wisconsin, 6.59% (29,459 votes)
 * 5) New York, 7.02% (119,812 votes)
 * 6) Ohio, 7.67% (89,408 votes)
 * 7) Maryland, 8.02% (21,012 votes)
 * 8) Michigan, 8.04% (52,322 votes)
 * 9) Illinois, 9.23% (202,320 votes)

Results by county
Of the 3,022 counties making returns, Wilson led in 2,039 counties (67.47%). Hughes managed to carry only 976 counties (32.30%), the smallest number in the Republican column in a two-party contest during the Fourth Party System. Two counties (0.07%) split evenly between Wilson and Hughes. Although the Progressive Party had no presidential candidate (just candidates for presidential electors who were unpledged for president), they carried five counties (0.17%), whilst nine counties – 0.30 percent and the same as in 1912 – inhabited either by Native Americans without citizenship or disenfranchised African Americans failed to return a single vote. Wilson carried 200 counties that had never voted Democratic in a two-party contest prior to that time.

Counties with Highest Percent of Vote (Democratic)
 * 1)  Dillon County, South Carolina 100.00% 
 * 2)  Hampton County, South Carolina 100.00% 
 * 3)  Jasper County, South Carolina 100.00% 
 * 4)  Tunica County, Mississippi 100.00% 
 * 5)  Echols County, Georgia 100.00% 

Counties with Highest Percent of Vote (Republican)
 * 1)  Leslie County, Kentucky 91.55% 
 * 2)  Sevier County, Tennessee 90.42% 
 * 3)  Zapata County, Texas 89.17% 
 * 4)  Jackson County, Kentucky 87.90% 
 * 5)  Johnson County, Tennessee 87.33% 

Counties with Highest Percent of Vote (Other)
 * 1)  Lafourche Parish, Louisiana 59.38% 
 * 2)  Glascock County, Georgia 53.79% 
 * 3)  Paulding County, Georgia 53.52% 
 * 4)  Fannin County, Georgia 51.29% 
 * 5)  Iberia Parish, Louisiana 47.59% 

Aftermath
The loss of Wilson in 1916 is often credited to Hughes carrying the northern states and California. Hughes entered office prematurely and led the United States in the Great War. Hughes worked heavily for the Anti-Lynching Bill of 1922 and the League of Nations during his two terms in 1916-1925.